|Original airdate:||May 2, 2020|
|Previous episode:||A Family's Nightmare|
|Next episode:||Holiday Homicide|
Kelly and Abbey return to Florida to help the Fort Myers Police Department investigate the 1997 murder of Keith Jones, an aspiring police officer robbed and fatally shot in his motel room. The suspects include four local men and a female witness that may have set him up.
- Kelly Siegler as Prosecutor Kelly Siegler
- Abbey Abbondandolo as Homicide Investigator Abbey Abbondandolo
- Lieutenant Victor Medico (Fort Myers Police Department)
- Detective Emily Destefanis (Fort Myers Police Department)
- Sergeant Lesa Breneman (Fort Myers Police Department)
- Marcia Hall (Keith's Sister)
- Kevin Jones (Keith's Brother)
- Preston Jones, Sr. (Keith's Father)
- Fort Myers, Florida (June 19, 1997)
- Keith Jones (27)
- Michelle Ashley (Michelle Jackson) - on October 22, 2019 Michelle Jackson was arrested for the murder of Keith Jones.
- Jamel Anthony Manson
- Phillip Lafettye Boyd
- Gerard Jules, Jr.
- Richard Vivien Fraser