|Fool Me Once, Fool Me Twice?|
|Original airdate:||August 15, 2014|
|Previous episode:||Second Thoughts|
|Next episode:||Still of the Night|
Kathy Taylor, 23, was a happy, vibrant young woman with her whole life ahead of her. In October 1973, she married the dashing, gregarious 22-year-old Earl Taylor. The couple had a short courtship, fell in love and quickly wed. On April 2, 1975, Earl reportedly returned home from some errands and called out for Kathy, but got no reply. He told police he found his wife submerged in the bathtub, an electric clock radio sunk beneath her. She was declared dead from an apparent electrocution and drowning, although questions have lingered about how Kathy died and why. To this day, Kathy's 82-year-old mother Maxine and sister Bonnie still are searching for the truth. Last winter, the Cold Justice team helped Vigo County Sheriff's Office Captain John Moats and Detective Eric Fell in the investigation of the 1998 murder of Erika Case, and in January, Clint Mackey, who'd been a prior "person of interest," was arrested for Erika's murder after giving a detailed confession. Cold Justice and the Vigo County Sheriff's Office are teaming up once again, and Captain Moats hopes they'll be able to resolve what really happened to Kathy. After almost 40 years, this will be the oldest case the Cold Justice team has taken.
- Kelly Siegler as Prosecutor Kelly Siegler
- Yolanda McClary as Crime Scene Investigator Yolanda McClary
- Steve Spingola as Homicide Investigator Steve Spingola
- Detective Derek Fell (Vigo County Sheriff's Office)
- Captain John Moats (Vigo County Sheriff's Office)
- Vigo County, Indiana (April 2, 1975)
- Kathy Taylor (23)
- Earl Taylor (husband) - sentenced to life in prison without parole.
|Cold Justice season 2|
|Episodes||Gone • A Monster Among Us • High School Sweethearts • First Love • He Said, He Said • Ambush • Single Working Mom • Billy Goat Hill • Lady in the Box • Copper Dollar Ranch • Stranded • Death by Design? • Kirby's Speed Shop • Justice Served (1) • Sunspot Highway • Other Side of the Tracks • Second Thoughts • Fool Me Once, Fool Me Twice?|
|Other Seasons||Season 1 • Season 3 • Season 4 • Season 5 • Season 6|