Kelly and Abbey head to Colorado to help the Prowers County Sheriff's Office investigate the 1991 homicide of a beloved elderly couple who were brutally killed while working at their local VFW Hall.
- Prowers County, Colorado (August 1, 1991)
- Robert “Curly” Culberth (70)
- Darlene Culberth (51)
- Robert Filbeck - was arrested for investigation of murder, he was never formally charged with murder and was later released.