Cold Justice Franchise Wiki
Mystery on the Mountain
Season: 5
Episode: 21
Original airdate: March 28, 2020
Episode chronology
Previous episode: Small Town Predator
Next episode: Double Life Discovered


Kelly and Abbey work with the Shoshone County Sheriff’s Office to investigate the 2012 disappearance of Brian Shookman, a young father who traveled to the county to attend a family reunion, and then vanished. As the list of suspects grows, can the team uncover the truth behind his vanishing?


  • Kelly Siegler as Prosecutor Kelly Siegler
  • Abbey Abbondandolo as Homicide Investigator Abbey Abbondandolo
  • Keisha Oxendine (Shoshone County Prosecuting Attorney)
  • Sergeant Jared Bilaski (Shoshone County Sheriff's Office)
  • Detective Jeff Lee (Shoshone County Sheriff's Office)
  • Rebecca Banning Shookman (Brian's Mother)
  • Jennifer Anselmo (Brian's Sister)
  • Jamie Hill (Justin's Friend)
  • Joshua Easley (Justin's Friend)
  • Steven Anderson (Justin's Friend)
  • Travis Quimby (Justin's Friend)


  • Shoshone County, Idaho (July 28, 2012)


  • Brian Shookman (32)


  • Shawn Beare
  • Danny Tetrault
  • Christina Korff
  • Justin Smith

Case Status

On July 24th, 2019, the Shoshone County Sheriff's and District Attorney's offices conducted a thorough search of the Dobson Pass area. Brian Shookman's remains were not found. The investigation into this case will continue.

Cold Justice season 5
Episodes Small Town SecretsThe Professor's EndHolding Onto HopeDown by the LakeDanger at DawnPreacher's MotherNo Safe ReturnBound and BurntPain in PawhuskaThe Case Behind the BillboardsDeath Among Him, Part 1Death Among Him, Part 2Backwater BloodshedGolden Years GoneA Mother's Dying WishTexas TragedyFamily BetrayalHorror in the HomeValentine's Day ViolenceSmall Town PredatorMystery on the MountainDouble Life DiscoveredDigging for AnswersDeadly AffairsA Family's NightmareFatal Betrayal
Other Seasons Season 1Season 2Season 3Season 4Season 6Season 7