Cold Justice Franchise Wiki
Small Town Predator
Season: 5
Episode: 20
Original airdate: March 21, 2020
Episode chronology
Previous episode: Valentine's Day Violence
Next episode: Mystery on the Mountain


In Lawrence County, Missouri, Kelly and Johnny work with the Lawrence County Sheriff’s Office to tackle the 1988 murder of Cindi Smith, a woman whose body was found at a cemetery after a night at a local bar. The patrons of the bar could hold the key to identifying her killer and getting her family justice.


  • Kelly Siegler as Prosecutor Kelly Siegler
  • Johnny Bonds as Homicide Investigator Johnny Bonds
  • Lieutenant Chris Berry (Lawrence County Sheriff's Office)
  • Sergeant Melissa "Mo" Phillips (Lawrence County Sheriff's Office)
  • Doctor Kathryn Pinneri, M.D. (Forensic Pathologist)
  • Shawn Goodspeed (Cindy's Son)
  • Jason Smith (Cindy's Son)
  • Tanya Lewis (Checkers' Patron)
  • Deedee Meyers (Checkers' Patron)
  • Jimmy Brashears (Checkers' Patron)
  • Marilyn Chambers (Cindy's Friend)
  • Janice Medlin (Cindy's Friend)
  • Louis Ed Smith (Ex-Husband)


  • Lawrence County, Missouri (July 28, 1988)


  • Cynthia Smith (31)


  • Lawrence Gene "Larry" Timmons - On September the 6th, 2019, Larry Timmons was indicted and arrested by the Lawrence County Sheriff's Department for the murder of Cindi Smith.

Cold Justice season 5
Episodes Small Town SecretsThe Professor's EndHolding Onto HopeDown by the LakeDanger at DawnPreacher's MotherNo Safe ReturnBound and BurntPain in PawhuskaThe Case Behind the BillboardsDeath Among Him, Part 1Death Among Him, Part 2Backwater BloodshedGolden Years GoneA Mother's Dying WishTexas TragedyFamily BetrayalHorror in the HomeValentine's Day ViolenceSmall Town PredatorMystery on the MountainDouble Life DiscoveredDigging for AnswersDeadly AffairsA Family's NightmareFatal Betrayal
Other Seasons Season 1Season 2Season 3Season 4Season 6Season 7