Cold Justice Franchise Wiki
Small Town Secrets
Season: 5
Episode: 1
Original airdate: August 4, 2018
Episode chronology
Previous episode: Covet
Next episode: The Professor's End


Kelly and Steve Spingola head to Wisconsin to investigate an unsolved homicide. The case becomes personal after they receive a letter from the victim's daughters. Their search uncovers a town's dark side, crimes against children and lies within a church.



  • Oneida County, Wisconsin (April 28, 1982)


  • Barbara Mendez (33)


  • Robin "Bob" Mendez - Judge Jill Falstad sentenced Robin "Bob" Mendez to life in prison for the "heinous" and "vicious" murder of his wife Barbara more than three decades ago.

Cold Justice season 5
Episodes Small Town SecretsThe Professor's EndHolding Onto HopeDown by the LakeDanger at DawnPreacher's MotherNo Safe ReturnBound and BurntPain in PawhuskaThe Case Behind the BillboardsDeath Among Him, Part 1Death Among Him, Part 2Backwater BloodshedGolden Years GoneA Mother's Dying WishTexas TragedyFamily BetrayalHorror in the HomeValentine's Day ViolenceSmall Town PredatorMystery on the MountainDouble Life DiscoveredDigging for AnswersDeadly AffairsA Family's NightmareFatal Betrayal
Other Seasons Season 1Season 2Season 3Season 4Season 6